Clean Line Gel Liner - Eyeliner

Good product

It was alright. Not as clean of a finish as I would have liked but good waterproof. Looked good

Meh

It’s very soft which means I’d have to sharpen it after each eye in order to keep a sharp tip ...which feels a little wasteful.I also found that it didn’t set as much as I’d hoped. By the end of the day it had smudged onto the lower eye. The pigment is rich, though. Just wish it had a bit more staying power.

Great Product

This is probably the best eye liner I’ve found to date. It applies a thin line and stays with you all day. Will purchase again.

Lovely, but it Smudges

Lovely glide, dusk is an amazing color, but this liner smudges too much compared with other liners. I will try using the tiniest amount and setting it with a powder shadow and see if that works.

Not for long wear imo :(

this was nice and blend-able but it smudged a lot through my day :(

No smear and last all day!

I have a problem with most eye makeup and cosmetics can’t have anything with retinol and I have to be careful with the chemicals in them because I’m allergic to everything so that’s why I started using Ilia started with the mascara then I went to the eyeliner and now I’m using the concealer, lipgloss, color, sticks, eyeliner, and mascara, and the foaming face cleaner I love all of it. I’m not breaking out for any of it. I’ve used it for a couple of years now, so my allergy issues are pretty much gone except on a really windy day and then my eyes do bother me, but I don’t know if it’s the eyeliner or the mascara.

Like butter!!

Great color, goes on so smooth! Easy to use- can even make perfect winged look.Can create thin or thick lines.

Smooth and creamy eyeliner

Love the formula and color! I did experience a tiny bit of smudging, but not a deal breaker.

Perfect in the water line. And since it’s clean it never irritates or turns eyes red. Super clean and stays all day and night. Been using it for years / nothing better.

Love it

Glides on and like the color. Very happy to buy clean products

Broke after a few uses

The dark brown was a great color. I really liked it the first few weeks I used it and it sharpened without issue at first, then the sharpener completely broke off a chunk and now it won’t sharpen anymore. Perhaps this one was just defective, but I won’t be repurchasing.

Brown Clean Line Gel Liner

Love this eyeliner!!! Application is very smooth and lasts a loooong time. No smudging or fading.