Colorful Lidschatten - Matte Wirkung

Good shadow but keeps getting smaller

Love this eyeshadow color (roasted chestnuts) and it applies well. I've been using it for years but this last order (5/16/25) will be my last. Why? Because the packaging just keeps getting smaller and smaller. I'm looking for a replacement that is a better value for my money. I'm including a photo that shows my old shadow on the left and the shadow I just purchased on the right. Mind you, when I originally bought the shadow on the left, it too was a downsize from many years ago. Now it's just getting ridiculous.

Doesn’t stay on

Not very good because it doesn’t stay on and rubs off through the day even with primer and sealer.

Impossible To Open

The new packaging is terrible. You cannot open the case. I broke a nail trying to pry it open. I then tried to pry it open with tweezers while in turn sent the eyeshadow flying onto the ground and the powder completely smashed. I have used these eye shadows for years. Disappointed in the new case. Hope the company changes it soon.

Can’t open. Junk!

Impossible to open. Again, changed an old product and made it worse

Staple!!!

The Sephora eyeshadows are a staple in my daily routine. I appreciate the shade range and that the brand is clean, so it doesn’t irritate my eyes. The 306 colour is my fav! Adds a little something without being too much

good

good product, nice colour, good application with little to no fall out. the size is way too small for the price, honestly just spend a little more for a whole palette because i dont think this is worth it.

So disappointed

It's definitely not as good as the old eyeshadow, and I miss my old mocha shade. This does not cut it.

Mocha Latte

Color is much darker than it looks online. I was really looking forward to this tiny shadow thinking it was the color I wanted. I suppose this is an in-store find.

Easy to open from the side

Its pigment is pretty good. It’s easy to open from the side. Don’t break a nail trying to open from where you are supposed to.

A suggestion for fixing the case

Product is great. Case is extremely difficult to open. There’s a notch by the hinge that you can slip a thin object like a file into to pry the lid open. Then I used clippers to trim the locking piece into a V. Remove your shadow first so it doesn’t get wrecked. Hope this helps!

Used as concealer

Bought this not for the eyes, but as a concealer. An influencer said 106 and 109 is going viral in Asia. It totally works and honestly? I'm loving it better than an actual concealer. I'm in the medium category so it is bright on me but i'm totally sold. It's not chalky, pigmented just enough for what i need.

Very hard to open, you will break or chip a nail trying to open this product. Not sure if I want to like the product if this is going to be the case every time I try using it.